Recently, Senator Marco Rubio of Florida has been hinting at stripped-down version of the DREAM Act -- the legislation which sought to provide a path to legal status, through collegiate study or military service, for undocumented immigrants who came to the United States at a young age. 23-year-old Rosario Quiroz is one of those immigrants, and she wants her own DREAM Act in New York State.
Rosario, a 2011 Columbia University graduate, remains undocumented. Earlier this week, adopting the slogan "Undocumented, Unafraid, Unapologetic," she joined with two other members of the New York State Youth Leadership Council (NYSYLC) -- Janet Perez and Sara Martinez -- in a peaceful protest intended to urge the as-yet unresponsive Governor Andrew Cuomo to include the New York DREAM Act in the upcoming state budget. They were arrested, and now face charges of disorderly conduct.
Melissa today recognized these three women as Foot Soldiers, and my interview with Rosario is below. The "Foot Soldiers" segment is embedded at the bottom.
First things first -- what led you to become involved in this cause?
I moved to the United States when I was seven, and I've been through the whole process of applying to college and just feeling the anxiety of not know whether I'd be able to pay for it because I knew I wouldn't be eligible for any financial aid and even for many scholarships. I worked very hard throughout high school. I feel that I empathize with people who are for the New York Dream Act, which would allow undocumented students accessibility to state funds for college. (In other words), state financial aid would be made available to undocumented youth.
I know that you're a recent Columbia grad. How did you end up paying for school?
Columbia is a private university, and they have what's called needs-blind admissions. When I applied, it was for all North American citizens. So this meant if you're from Canada, or you're from Mexico, you can go to school there regardless of your financial situation and regardless of your citizenship. So, if your parents made below a certain amount, Columbia University covers the costs. There's a student contribution, but no parent contribution -- so I did have to work throughout the summer to get that money together. I was also awarded work-study, which was crazy because I wasn't eligible to work for the university. I had to work through the summer to make sure that I had the money to work throughout the year, and just making it last. I had an outside, private scholarship through a sponsor that was renewable for all four years, so I (also) had that support.
I understand that Mayor Bloomberg has endorsed the New York DREAM Act, but that Governor Cuomo has been unresponsive so far. How is the effort going so far?
First, there was a huge push for the federal DREAM Act, which was shot down, again, at the end of 2010. After that, that is when the NYSYLC decided to push for this (state) act specifically. In terms of the process, it was presented over a year ago. Governor Cuomo has had the opportunity to look at ways to include it in the budget, but he hasn't made any mention of doing so.
Tell me about how you got involved with advocating for the federal DREAM Act.
I got involved, probably, in my freshman year in high school. This was because my mom was very involved with the community, and I remember, one time, going to a statewide forum for Latinos -- and they talked about this DREAM Act. At that point, I was already of the situation, but not fully aware of how it would impact me. I wanted to go to college, so I saw this as a possibility for the future, thinking, "if it passes before I go there, I'll have the means to go to college, and a pathway to citizenship."
We talked about the DREAM Act a lot (in one of my high school clubs) and we advocated for it with petitions. I grew up in North Carolina, and I went to a school that was very small -- 400 students total. I remember it was a huge thing for us that we got half of the student body to sign (our petition) -- during lunch, after school, having a table with information about the DREAM Act, what it would do, how it would impact people -- and so, yeah, it started there. Then it turned into calls to senators and to representatives.
Then I got to New York, and I saw the work that was being done by (the NYSYLC), and they were doing more than talking. They were letting undocumented youth know that they were here as a support system for us, that it's OK that we're undocumented, and that the stigma that's been there isn't fair. We can get past that. We can get past this.
Last week was the third-annual coming-out rally, which was probably the most powerful thing I'd ever seen. Before that, my closest friends knew that I was undocumented, close friends that I'd known for a decade or more, a select few people. You don't know who to trust; there's this idea that people could call immigration on you at any moment, so if it's talked about, it's talked about behind closed doors. That's a matter that is kept very private.
Is that how you had to grow up -- having to live your life on pins and needles all the time?
It was. For me, I had a good childhood; I had friends who are undocumented who didn't even find out their status until they were applying to college, and that wasn't my case. My parents were very open with us, such as when we asked why can't we go to Mexico to visit my grandparents, and see my family, we knew that it's because if we leave, we're not coming back. (It was like,) "This is just the sacrifice we have to make for the time being. Hopefully, eventually something will come up where we can apply for citizenship, but right now, there's no way. This is just something that we have to do."
The first time that it hit me was when I won a competition with a Boys & Girls Club that I was part of, and I had to travel to the state competition...eight hours away. It was in the state, but it's such a long state that it was a lot of travel time, and I needed to fly. And for that, I needed an ID. I tried to go to the DMV with my tax ID number and my expired tourist visa, and I remember getting there and -- at this point, the laws in North Carolina were changing to the point where undocumented immigrants were no longer able to get their licenses there. So I remember they turned my tourist visa around and said, "Look, it says right here this is not valid six months from your point of entry, this is expired, and it's not valid 100 miles north of the border... I'm gonna call immigration on you." I was 15 years old, and just terrified. My mom was there with me, thank God. He wrote the number down and told us to leave. I bolted out the door, got in the car, and just started crying.
That was my first experience with knowing that being undocumented would have more effects than just not being able to go visit family.
After Columbia, what happens? Are you dealing with obstacles in your job search after your graduation?
Yeah. The job obstacle is always there. I am working right now. I have a part-time job babysitting, and a part-time fellowship with an organization that does know my situation, and they have been very supportive.
You have this degree; it just seems that you're unable to use it. Why do you feel Governor Cuomo has been so reticent about adding the New York DREAM Act to the state budget?
I guess it just depends upon what you prioritize. I guess it's easy to forget undocumented folks, because for a long time, our communities have been scared to stand up for themselves. A lot of undocumented immigrants pay taxes, and contribute to this society -- and it's not like we're getting those benefits back, in terms of things like Social Security. As far as the economic situation in the country, everyone is worried, and everyone is struggling. But at the same time, I don't know -- I don't know if it's just easier to view the undocumented community as a very powerless section of society, so it's easy to overlook our needs. But at the same time, I think that it needs to be made a point of that we are contributing to society, and our labor is essential, and at the core of making a lot of other things possible. That needs to be recognized.
I wish that I could ask Governor Cuomo this question: why haven't you included this? To me, it's shameful. What his inaction is saying is that we youth are worthless. We're not going to contribute. And how can they say this, when we've worked so hard? An educated society is (inherently) going to contribute more.
Tell me about your arrest.
The street was blocked off, the banners were dropped, and we each sat on a banner. There were other people who were sitting on them, but the cops arrived and warned us that we would be arrested. Some people got up and went back to the sidewalk. We stayed there, we were arrested, and taken to the 17th precinct. We were held there for two hours, then we were booked and went through the system, because we didn't have state IDs. Our student IDs, they really couldn't do anything with that. We were fingerprinted, and our pictures were taken. Then we were taken to central booking, went through that whole process, spent the night in jail -- and then we saw the judge in the morning. We are taking the case to trial. We were charged with disorderly conduct, and we have court on April 25.
We'll follow up with you to find out what happens. I know you did this for the movement and other people in your situation, but is there any personal fulfillment you've gotten out of this?
Yes. It's been beneficial personally. Throughout the process, through the uncertainty, the selfless aspect of it kept me strong. I was able to say to myself, "you're going to be fine regardless; what will come out of this will be beneficial to others, and it could pay off more than it could even cost." But in terms of personal fulfillment, it was almost a test for myself: a test of my courage, because I feel that these are things I've been talking about -- the cause, the movement, social justice -- and these are things I'm constantly thinking about and pushing for, even in conversations with friends. I've always been so frustrated because it always ends in talk. Even within academia, there's so much focus on what's wrong with the system, and with sociology (her collegiate major), it was always so frustrating.
I feel like I wanted to get past that. It's like, no, we can't just focus on the problems; what's the point of that? No, we have to start focusing on alternatives -- but how do we get to alternatives? By taking action! To me, this action shows that it's possible. I can't expect anyone to have the courage to step forward, and really start pushing for alternatives, and holding politicians accountable for things that they believe to be right. It was a testament to (my being able) to do this.
In terms of my career goals, I'm still kind of at a place where I have no idea what I want to do, but I do know that I want to help people in a very real way. I want to help them in a way that empowers them, that shows them their own light. So, I'm just going to continue pushing for change, and it's going to take a lot of acting from a place of selflessness, and not anger, because I was angry for a long time. This feels like my first step towards what I want to do with my life.
Foot Soldiers: Three young women pushing for the New York State Dream Act were arrested on Wednesday in front of Gov. Andrew Cuomo's office, as they "came out" with their undocumented status in protesting for a chance at the American Dream.



Melissa Harris Perry, what a great show finally someone who can address the race issue without an attitude. Total honesty as to how to address Black people. Explaining the things that we find offensive and using the right language. Thank God that someone know how to have the conversation. AndSte
The dream act is just another excuse to let people who came here illegally in the first place to stay and get full privilege's. I think its all wrong and although these 3 were brought here by there parents its still breaking the law.
These 3 and many more like them from Mexico or other countries could have went through the proper channels to apply for citizenship in the time they have all been here but have they? NO, Why?
Guess its just easier to break the laws of the U.S. and wait for some kind of "Dream Act"
I understand people wanting a better life, but its how these people go about it that pisses me off to no end.
Its all about "Wanting" what they want etc etc etc, I'm tired of hearing and seeing Spanish spoken in the USA, as its being forced on the true Americans and again that's not right but who cares anymore as this country is going down the toilet fast and "ILLEGAL ALIENS" have a lot to do with it.
I was raised to respect all people no matter what the color of there skin etc but when those people don't respect me or follow the law, Then I have a big problem and its going to get worse before it gets better.
"I think its all wrong and although these 3 were brought here by there parents" -- It's spelled "their" and..... children should not be punished for the actions of their parents.
"These 3 and many more like them from Mexico" -- They're not from Mexico. They've lived here all their lives since a very young age. They are no different than you and I with the exception they were brought here as children by their parents.
"Guess its just easier to break the laws of the U.S." -- They have broken no laws.
"I'm tired of hearing and seeing Spanish spoken in the USA" -- Racist.
"I was raised to respect all people no matter what the color of there skin" -- It's spelled "their". How is accusing children of having committed crimes they did not commit showing respect?
And if people are truly equal, then what makes her better than all the other undocumented, or would-be undocumented people because you do realize what it actually means if we open our borders and allow every person who wants to to come in right?
So I say, lets go ahead, give these people what they want, let them come in and be undocumented all they want, and then when our economy suddenly crashes from the strain of sudden way over population and we become a third world nation because now nobody can even afford to leave, except of course the undocumented who are already citizens of another country, we can all finally learn the hard way what Conservatives have already learned.
And then of course before we actually crash to a third world economy, even the most ardent Liberal employed, in the face of certain collapse and the subsequent destitution, will desperately be scratching around looking for a way to restrict the amounts of undocumented people flooding in.
Oh wait, but we're actually already doing that . . . hmmmm, you Liberals live in a dream world of fuzzy bunnies and candy canes, but real life is actually what's happening. Quit Liberals, say no to your liberally induced high and think realistically. Unless, of course, you want to say that some are better than others, which is something you Liberals are already saying in many many aspects of U.S. society.
"because you do realize what it actually means if we open our borders and allow every person who wants to to come in right?" --- No one is talking about opening the borders. The Dream Act certainly does nothing of the sort.
"and then when our economy suddenly crashes from the strain of sudden way over population and we become a third world nation [...] we can all finally learn the hard way what Conservatives have already learned." ---- Immigrants don't harm the economy, they grow it. The belief that they do is called the "Lump of Labor Fallacy".
"you Liberals live in a dream world of fuzzy bunnies and candy canes" -- No hun, We live in a world of cold hard facts. It is Liberals, not conservatives, who are the pragmatic realists of today.
Facts have a well known liberal bias.
Why does it matter if they have been here since childhood? They are here illegally. They are Mexican citizens and can go to college in Mexico. They have NO RIGHT to take away college fuding from LEGAL CITIZENS because their parents BROKE THE LAW and came here illegally!!! They and their families should be IMMEADIATELY DEPORTED!!!!! If they want citizen benefits they need to go back to Mexico, earn the money to come legally and follow legal prcedures to do so!! LOTS OF AMERICAN CITIZENS HAVE DREAMS TOO!!!! In no way is this fair to citizens and those from other countries that came in the proper way and followed all legal procedures. These 3 girls and all the other UNDOCUMENTEDS that want a free ride here need to be arrested and deported. They are criminals and thats the way they should be treated. Life is so bad in MEXICO GO HOME AND FIGHT FOR CHANGE AND REFORM IN YOUR OWN GOVERNMENT DON'T EXPECT ANOTHER COUNTRY TO SUPPORT YOU AND EDUCATE YOU. Elected officials that want undocumenteds to be given benefits beloning to CITIZENS SHOULD BE VOTED OUT, IMMPEACHED, FIRED OR JUST PLAIN RESIGN NOW!!!!!!!
"Why does it matter if they have been here since childhood?" -- Because children do not have a choice. Five year olds cannot break immigration laws. In a civilized society we do not hold people, especially children, accountable for crimes they did not commit.
"They are here illegally." -- So are you. So am I. No one asked the Native Americans for permission, we took their land by force.
"They have NO RIGHT to take away college fuding from LEGAL CITIZENS because their parents BROKE THE LAW and came here illegally!!!" --- Rick Perry, governor of the great state of Texas, disagrees with you. He agrees with ME and other liberals that it is in everyone's interest to have an educated populace. Education grows jobs and strengthens the economy.
"LOTS OF AMERICAN CITIZENS HAVE DREAMS TOO!!!!" -- No one is preventing you from achieving your dreams. Education is not a zero sum game. Both you AND the children of undocumented aliens can and should be able to have the opportunity to reach for their dreams. If you have failed maybe you should exercise that famous conservative value of personal responsibility and take a good long look in the mirror.
"They are criminals and thats the way they should be treated." --- They have committed no crimes.
"Elected officials that want undocumenteds to be given benefits beloning to CITIZENS SHOULD BE VOTED OUT, IMMPEACHED, FIRED OR JUST PLAIN RESIGN NOW!!!!!!!" ----- Well that is your opinion and you have the right to hold to that. But other people do not agree with you. In fact, people who agree with your hate and extremist racism and xenophobia are thankfully a distinct minority. Neither Ron Paul nor Rand Paul will EVER be president because no one wants to live in their dream of a racist society.
Well you can have your opinion but I absolutely disagree with your theory that I Shate anyone or am racist. IT I NOT RACIST to believe that lawbreakers do not deserve rewards. Plenty of other races need help to get thru college etc. Illegal law breakers don't deserve fundig over citizens plain and simple. College tutitions keep going up and up pricing many citizens out of an education right now. WHY should citizens of Mexico get those grants and scholarships before american citizens? Answer..they shouldn't. Why do you folks who accuse myself and others of similar opinion of hating and being racist never answer the folowing question..Why can't these law breakers go back to Mexico and fight for rights to education, etc..??Why can't they fight for reform to their political and law enforcement systems?? bEcause they might get killed??? Well, too bad. Plenty of Americans died fighting the revolutionary war to gain freedom for this country. If it can be done in America it can be done in Mexico. Instead of prostesting and picketing the american government to give them a free ride they should be asking our government to back them in fighting for their own country. You hate my so called racismn, I hate your giving away our country to foreigners, many who have no intentions of assimilating to American culture in ways such as learning the language, holding a job rather than collecting welfare, free medical care and subsidized housing. There are hundreds of thousands of American children living below the poverty line right now. THousads upon thousands of Americans in foster care systems that dump them with no assitance at 18, thousands more runaways living on the streets having to beg and sell their bodies to survive. The girls in this story could go to mexico and get into school there without a problem and they have parents that SHOULD be taking financial responsibilty but don't. What about the childre I cited who ARE AMERICANS??? Is your answer to them, tough @!$%#!!! FEderal and state dollars are better spent on law breakers than you poor abandoned and betrayed American kids??? Wo really is the hater here??? Think its you who refuse to put your OWN COUNTRYMEN AND COUNTRYWOMEN AND CHILDREN FIRST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
BTW oncoming storm-I am not a conservative. I am a registered Democrat who happens to believe we need to take care of our own citizens first.
This is a perfect example of why the Affordable Care Act is a law that must have the power of a Constitutional Mandate.
How many persons born in America are born outside of a hospital somewhere? Even in the illegal immigrant community that number is probably very low. That means that the state where they are born is acting independently of the Congress in granting or preventing citizenship to naturally born Americans. The same is the case for a young person who was brought here by their parents or some other adult.
The result of this being a disadvantaged resident who would be a citizen under the regulatory power given to the Congress through the Affordable Care Act. When Health Care has a constitutional power given to it, children can be protected under the law, reducing the burden on society and allowing the DREAM Act to be more robust.
And we have already ended slavery in America which is the real substantive concern in the discussion of illegal immigration. Undocumented should not mean excluded. I am sure that she has been fed, clothed, housed, and educated, instead of stealing, drug usage, or killing and I would be proud to have anyone like her as a fellow citizen. Good people are hard to come by. Don't forget that our founding fathers were all revolutionaries fleeing from tyranny!
HEALTH CARE IS A BLESSING OF LIBERTY THAT IS NOT NEGOTIABLE AND MAKES AMERICA WORTH DYING FOR!
undocumented should =sent back to where they came from. Mexican citizens need to get their health care, housing, college education etc.. from their own government. If they are downtroden, underpaid, underprotected by their law enforcement and underducated by their government they need to stand up and fight for their rights in their OWN country not get a free ride here.
The ending of slavery and illeal immigration have nothing to do with each other. Undocumented should exactly mean excluded. Thousands upon thousands of American citizens can't get enough or any health care. Why are we going to give away funding for citizens to udocumenteds??? Why shouldn't our own countrymen be robust workers in this nation instead of poor, unemployed (because illegals took their jobs) sick and dying because they have no healthcare while illeagals are getting health care foodstamps, housing, educational opportunities etc.. Giving our hard earned tax moneies to support and educate undocumented/illegal aliens is one of the biggest TRAVESTY"S of JUSTICE going on in our country today!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ms Harris-Perry, I would like to thank you, on behalf of black men everywhere, for having the courage to continue covering the Trayvon Martin story. It seems that many people would prefer to sweep the plight of black men in this country out of our collective conscience. It is so very important that educated black women who attain success in this country help the black men, who are still struggling, to put the history of their oppression, and enslavement, behind them. I'd just like to add, in closing, that a certain media giant, that I won't name, whose initials are O.W., has been strangely silent on this subject...I guess it isn't ratings worthy.